I don't know when it started, but he frequently asks questions, "Are bad guys happy?" "Do bad guys get presents?" "Do bad guys get dessert?" "Do bad guys lie?"
Often these "bad guys" are exempt from the normal protections we offer to good guys. Like, it's not ok to push Matthew or other children, but "it's ok to push bad guys."
I am not entirely sure if I'm doing the right thing by saying it is ok to push bad guys, because of the whole "love thy enemies thing" but sometimes I envision these bad guys being the sort of people that sneak into bedroom windows at night to try to take things...and yeah, in cases like those, it's ok to push them.
Since loving thy enemies is a more sophisticated teaching in the pedagogy of morality, we're still at rudimentary principles: good guys are happy and don't get punished, bad guys are sad and do get punished. So in our house, bad guys are not offered much in terms of mercy. That can come later. In our house, bad guys are the most unlikeable types for whom nothing goes well.
Michael does not like bad guys. Somehow, even "hating" them crept into his vocabulary (where does he get that? Do I say I hate stuff? I didn't think so....) He talks about them all the time. He likes to emphasize the fact that they don't get things he gets to have. I like this. I want him to see that being good is what you want to do because then you'll be happy and it's how you get all that really matters. In all honesty, it's the Beatitudes adapted to a 3 year old boy's mentality: Blessed (happy) are the peacemakers, blessed are the meek...etc...they get the good stuff.
At lunch today, Michael surprised us by his dislike of the bad buys when he told us, step by step what he was going to do with the bad buys.
"I'm going to get the bad guys."
-"What will you do with them?"
"Put them in the basket."
-"Then what will you do with them?"
"I'm going to dump them in the parking lot."
-"What will happen once they are in the parking lot?"
"They'll get squished by a car."
-"Who will drive the car?"
"Mommy and Daddy and Michael and Matthew."
Michael Sr and I are cracking up, on the one hand slightly disturbed by the violent nature with which he will deliver justice against the bad guys. On the other hand, aware that at a certain point, this is not much less violent than the Biblical teaching of the Wheat and the Tares. I mean, does it not say in Matthew 13:36-43 that, "The Son of Man will send out his angels, and they will gather out of his Kingdom all things that cause stumbling, and those who do iniquity, and will cast them into the furnace of fire. There will be weeping and the gnashing of teeth."
So, we're going to let this be in our home for a while to further cement how undesirable it is to be a bad guy. I'm sure as time goes on, we can develop who the bad guys are, and make sure to always teach mercy and the willingness of our Lord to forgive anyone who asks for it. But, if this is a good springboard to make them want to avoid being a bad guy and do the things that good guys do: praying, being kind, listening to Mommy and Daddy, going to Church, etc, then I think we are heading on the right track.
In the meantime, if Michael comes up to you in a parking lot with a basket in hand, I would go the other way.


